I am sorry to report that one of the early reviews of the new movie with Adrian Sparks as Hemingway and Giovanni Ribisi as Ed Meyers, a young journalist, was pretty sour. Beyond loving the Cuban scenery, the description of the movie as wooden is an “ouch” moment. Instead of flashing back to some of Hemingway’s allure and greatness, it sticks with his last two years, admittedly not his glory days. I would guess, given that time frame, that there is much drunkenness and fights with wife # 4, Mary. So disappointing. Below is the full review. Best, Christine
Papa Hemingway in Cuba
By DAN LYBARGER Special to the Democrat-Gazette
This article was published April 29, 2016 at 1:53 a.m.
68 Cast: Giovanni Ribisi, Adrian Sparks, Joely Richardson, Minka Kelly, Shaun Toub, James Remar, Mariel Hemingway
Director: Bob Yari
Rating: R, for language, sexuality, some violence and nudity
Running time: 109 minutes
In real life they might have been, but neither screenwriter Denne Bart Petitclerc, who actually knew the title character, nor director Bob Yari (better known as a producer of Crash and The Illusionist) has anything worthwhile to say about Ernest Hemingway or his time there.
Petitclerc has been dead for 10 years, and it’s easy to see why his script sat on the shelf until recently. If he had any unique insights into the Nobel Prize winner and his writing, none have made it into the final cut of this film.
As played by Adrian Sparks, Hemingway is a famous but drunken has-been. When he’s not fishing, he’s prone to bouts of paranoia and yelling matches with his wife, Mary (Joely Richardson). The writer hangs out with veterans of the Spanish Civil War and appears to have ties to the Cuban Revolution. He’s unable at this point in his 59 years to turn a blank sheet of paper into something magical.
Most of this stuff could be gleaned from a high school literature class or from listening to a barroom blowhard unable to discern truth from fiction. Without having samples from Hemingway’s clipped but often powerful prose, viewers are simply given the impression that he was an obnoxiously pompous bore who liked swimming naked. Petitclerc gives Sparks and Richardson plenty of excuses to yell at each other, but one quickly wonders why anyone ever sought these two out.
Instead of examining the author’s complicated life or re-creating the tension that surrounded the fall of Batista’s Cuba, Petitclerc and Yari decide to rehash the old cliche about never meeting your idols. In this case, Petitclerc’s stand-in for himself, Ed Myers (Giovanni Ribisi), writes Hemingway a fan letter and then hides it because he’s not sure if the note is worthy of the great writer’s time. Ed’s girlfriend (Minka Kelly) saves the letter from the waste basket and sends it to Cuba.
Much of the material seems to have been cobbled together from something that might seem more at home on The Hallmark Channel or Lifetime. On second thought, those movies are delivered with more subtlety and craftsmanship. Many shots seem stiff and clumsy, as if the only prerequisite for a successful take was that the actors were standing and breathing.
The folks behind those quickly made offerings might know better than to cast a 42-year-old as a cub reporter. It’s odd to hear Sparks and Richardson call Ribisi “the kid.”
The Revolution, which has been depicted in great films like The Godfather: Part II, Steven Soderbergh’s Che and Mikhail Kalatozov’s I Am Cuba, is prime fodder for great drama, but when Ed has to tell Santo Trafficante (James Remar) to his face that he runs the mob in Cuba, it’s a sign that Petitclerc has no idea how to tell the audience who characters are without having to telegraph the fact.
At least we can see why Hemingway loved Cuba; whenever the stiff, profanity-laden dialogue ends and the people leave the landscape, nature reveals an island full of lush vegetation and gorgeous seascapes. It’s also great to see the distinctive architecture, like Havana’s Malecon seawall, and to hear the infectious music that comes from the island. If Yari were a more capable director (this is only his second effort in a 30-something-year career), he might have put the music more prominently in the mix to drown out Petitclerc’s drivel.
MovieStyle on 04/29/2016
Print Headline: Papa Hemingway in Cuba
9 thoughts on “Review of New Movie: Papa Hemingway in Cuba–Not too good”
That’s too bad. I think I will still see it, though. Maybe someday someone will make a good Hem movie. Cheers, Denise
Hi Denise! Hope all is well. how is your novel coming? My Hemingway’s Daughter book is moving along! Very best!
I am glad to hear that the book is progressing. Me? Not so much . . . Will you be attending the Hemingway Conference in Oak Park in June? I’m gonna go. Cheers, Denise
Thanks, Denise! Don’t abandon the book though. I loved it. Best, Christine
I saw the film yesterday. It is not a docudrama. It is a remembrance by a young man of his literary hero.
What the film depicts is how the wife remembers being told what she had been told her now deceased husband remembered of his visits to the Finca Vigia and a troubled Papa.
There is much that could have been included if the scope of film had been broadened beyond the brief interactions shown. But that was not what the writer shared with us because he was not there as a witness. His perspective as a newspaper writer comes through. Perhaps, if he had been an editor who wrote for the oped page it would have been a different film.
Rather than look for what is not there enjoy the unchanged skyline. Celebrate the vintage automobiles still being driven just they were in 1959. Marvel at the interior views of the Things Vigia. Sense the tension of living amidst a violent revolution while being persecuted by the FBI while struggling with fear, paranoia, and critical depression. And watch the movie for the snapshot it is.
Thank you autocorrect for changing Finca.
Hi Ted: I agree. I will seeing it next weekend and while it may not be the movie we would have liked to see with more aspects of Hemingway, it still is nice to take away something of what the last years were like and to see Cuba and Hemingway’s home as it was. Thank you for reading. Best, Christine
Oh dear !!!!!! What a shame ………I’ll still be going to see it, though !!
Hi Angie: Yes, me too. I’ll enjoy it for what it is. I wish someone would do a really good movie and revive more interest in Hemingway and his writing. Ah well. Best, Christine